La Herradura II Mexican Restaurant Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to La Herradura II Mexican Restaurant, where authentic Mexican cuisine comes alive in Bargersville, IN. Nestled at 226 IN-135, this vibrant eatery offers a menu brimming with delightful options that cater to every palate. From the rich flavor of Chiles Poblanos to the sumptuous Quesadilla Birria, each dish is crafted with care and precision.

  • Vegetarian delights: Try the Mushroom Quesadilla or the flavorful Bean Tostaguac, both priced at just $11.99.
  • Quesadilla masterpieces: The Super Quesadilla, filled with steak, chicken, and shrimp, is a must-try at $15.99.
  • Refreshing salads: Don’t miss the La Flaka Salad, perfect for a lighter option at $10.25.

Each visit to La Herradura II promises an unforgettable experience, highlighted by friendly service and a welcoming atmosphere. It's no wonder patrons rave about their meals, eagerly returning to explore more!

House Favorites

Steak Indiana

T-Bone Or Rib-Eye with homemade potato wedges served with salad

US$19.99

La Pachanga

Sink your appetite into this platter of grilled steak grilled, chicken breast, and shrimp. Served with rice, beans and flour tortillas.

US$19.99

Mexican Pizza

Two layered flour tortillas, grilled and suffed with shrimp, strips steak, chicken breast, refried beans cheese, bell peppers, onions and tomatoes. Served with pico de gallo.

US$14.99

Quesadilla A La Diabla

A large quesadilla filled with grilled chicken and chorizo. Served with rice, beans lettuce, sour cream and tomatoes.

US$15.99

Quesadilla Fajita Grande

A large quesadilla filled with steak or chicken, grilled fajitas style. Served with rice and beans.

US$14.99

Quesadilla Tampico

A large quesadilla filled with shredded beef. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo.

US$13.99

Quesadilla Rellena

quesadilla with shredded beef or chicken with choice of rice or beans.

US$10.99

Quesadilla Herradura

Quesadilla filled with chunks of pork and pico de gallo, served with rice and salad.

US$15.99

Super Quesadilla

Favorite. A large quesadilla filled with chicken, steak and shrimp grilled fajita-style. Served with rice and beans with shrimps and vegetables.

US$15.99

Quesadillas De Camaron

One quesadilla filled with beans, cheese, onions and grilled shrimp with salad.

US$16.99

Quesadillas

Enchiladas

Enchiladas Sabrosas

Three grilled chicken enchiladas topped with cheese sauce salsa verde and sour cream. Served with rice and beans

US$13.50

Enchiladas De Mole

Three chicken enchiladas topped with mole sauce, Served with rice and beans.

US$11.99

Enchiladas Supreme

Supreme combo of four enchiladas, one chicken, one beef, one cheese and one shredded beef, topped with sour cream, salad and pico de gallo.

US$12.99

Spinach & Chicken Enchiladas

Three corn tortillas stuffed with chicken and spinach, topped with our delicious roasted poblano salsa. Served with rice and beans.

US$12.99

Enchiladas Mexicanas

Three corn tortillas, one with chicken, one with beef and one with cheese. Topped with three different sauces. Served with rice or beans.

US$12.99

Enchiladas Rancheras

Two cheese enchiladas with shredded pork, cooked with onions and bell peppers. Served with rice and beans.

US$13.99

Enchiladas Verdes

Three chicken enchiladas topped with tomatillo sauce. served with rice and beans

US$11.99

Enchiladas Chipotle

Three enchiladas, one shredded beef, one ground beef and one chicken. Topped with chipotle sauce, sour cream and pico de gallo. Served with rice and beans.

US$12.99

Chile Poblano With Rice, Beans, Lettuce, Tomatoes & Sour Cream

US$11.99

6. Mushroom Quesadilla With Rice & Beans

US$11.99

2. Chalupa & Cheese Enchilada With Rice & Beans

US$11.99

1. Bean Burrito, Cheese Enchilada & Bean Tostada

US$11.99

5. Bean Burrito, Cheese Enchilada & Cheese Quesadilla

US$11.99

3. Bean Burrito, Cheese Quesadilla & Chalupa

US$11.99

Chiles Poblanos

Two poblano peppers prepared in a special batter and deep fried. Topped with cheese and salsa. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$14.99

4. Bean Tostaguac, Cheese Enchilada & Rice

US$11.99

Vegetarian Enchiladas

Three enchiladas stuffed with sauteed mushrooms, bell peppers, onions and tomatoes, topped with cheese and tomatillo sauce. Served with rice, lettuce, sour cream, tomatoes and guacamole.

US$12.99

Vegetarian Fajita Nachos

Grilled fajita veggies on top of a bed of tortilla chips topped with cheese sauce.

US$12.99

Vegetarian

Nachos

Fajita Fries

Steak, chicken, and scaloops over bed of French fries, drizzled with cheese sauce topped with lettuce, sour cream, and pico de gallo.

US$16.99

Nachos Herradura

Favorite. The best of the house! Crisp tortilla chips layered with cheese dip and beans, grilled steak, chicken and shrimps. We add lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream and pico de gallo to make this a perfect pick.

US$17.99

Fajitas Nachos

Grilled steak or chicken sauteed with onions, red and green bell peppers.

US$13.25

Mixed Fajitas Nachos

Grilled steak and chicken with onions, red and green bell peppers.

US$13.25

Shrimp Nachos

Grilled shrimp sauteed with onions and green bell pepper.

US$16.99

Pork Nachos

Nachos with carnitas topped with cheese sauce, black beans, pico de gallo & pickled jalapeno.

US$15.99

Special Nachos

A mix of chicken, chorizo and applewood bacon, topped with refried beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, guacamole and pickled jalapenos.

US$13.25

Nachos Supreme

Ground beef or chicken topped with lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream.

US$10.99

Taco Salad

Flour tortilla bowl filled with ground beef or chicken, cheese beans, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream.

US$10.50

La Flaka Salad

Chopped romaine lettuce, tomato, onions, avocado, toasted corn, black beans, cucumber, queso fresco with a raspberry citrus vinaigrette dressing.

US$10.25

Crispy Chicken Salad

Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, peppers and cheese.

US$13.99

Chicken Fajita Salad

Grilled chicken over a bed of shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, cucumbers, avocado and cheese.

US$12.99

Herradura Salad

Grilled shrimp, chicken and mushroom with shredded lettuce, avocado, tomato and cheese.

US$15.99

Fajita Taco Salad

Taco salad filled with grilled chicken or steak, cheese, beans and cream salad.

US$13.99

Salad Camaron Mayito

Grilled shrimp,lettuce, onions, avocado slices and lime juice

US$16.50

Salads

Lunch Specials

8.Quesadilla And Two Tacos Lunch

Quesadilla filled with choice of Beef or chicken and two hard beef tacos.

US$9.50

2. Burrito Rice And Beans Lunch

US$9.50

5. Burrito, Taco And Rice Lunch

US$9.50

9. Beef Burrito And Beef Enchilada Lunch

Choice of rice or beans

US$9.50

3. Enchilada, Spinach And Chicken Quesadilla Lunch

Choice Rice or beans

US$9.50

6. Two Chicken Enchilada Lunch

Topped with Crema salad

US$9.50

10. Chicken Enchilada And Chicken Burrito

Topped with lettuce, sour cream and pico de Gallo

US$9.50

1. Speedy Gonzalez

taco enchilada, choice of rice or beans

US$9.50

7. Quesadilla Lunch Special

Quesadilla with choice of steak or chicken cooked with onions. Served with rice or beans and a salad

US$9.50

4. Chile Relleno, Taco, Rice And Beans Lunch

US$9.50

Chicken Fajita

Grilled tender sliced chicken.

US$16.50

Fajita De Lujo

Grilled steak, chicken, shrimp, carnitas, pork ribs and chorizo.

US$19.99

Texas Fajitas

Grilled steak, chicken and shrimp.

US$17.50

Vallarta Fajita

A mix of chorizo (Mexican sausage), grilled chicken and steak.

US$17.99

Shrimp Fajitas

Fresh tender shrimp.

US$18.50

Scallop Fajita

Scallops grilled with peppers and onions

US$22.99

Steak Fajita

Grilled steak.

US$16.50

Costillitas Con Zucchini

Tender pork ribs sauteed with zucchine, bell pepper, onions and tomatoes, topped with shredded cheese. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream, pico de gallo and tortillas.

US$19.99

Seafood Fajita

Shrimp, scallops and crab meat.

US$22.99

Mixed Fajita

Grilled chicken and steak.

US$16.50

Pina Loka

Grilled pineapple stuffed with chicken, steak, peppers and onions a al pastor sauce topped with melted cheese.

US$18.99

Fajitas Hawaiianas

Chicken, Bacon, Ham and pineapple

US$17.99

Veggie Fajita

Fresh grilled peppers, mushrooms, squash, carrots, tomato and onions.

US$14.99

Fajita Fundida

Grilled steak, pork and chorizo topped with cheese sauce

US$18.99

Sizzling Fajitas

Steak

California Steak And Shrimp

12 oz. Rib-Eye, grilled shrimp, california blend veggies, served with rice & beans

US$19.99

Carnitas Dinner

Pork cubes cooked till golden brown, delicately seasoned with spices and herbs. Served with pico de gallo, rice beans and flour tortillas.

US$15.99

Chile Colorado

Choice ribeye steak, smothered in red chili sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$14.99

La Pachanga

Sink your appetite into this platters or grilled steak, grilled chicken breast and shrimp. Served with rice, beans and flour tortillas.

US$19.99

Chile Verde Pork

Cooked with our special green sauce, served with rice beans and corn or flour tortillas.

US$14.99

Chori Steak

Grilled 12 oz t-bone steak covered with chorizo (Mexican sausage) and cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans.

US$17.99

Rib-Eye La Herradura

Rib-eye steak with baked potato topped with bacon white cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and peppers. Garnished with sour cream

US$21.99

Chile Verde Steak

Cooked with our special green sauce, served with rice beans and corn or flour tortillas.

US$14.99

Steak Ranchero

Served with guajillo sauce. Served with rice, beans, pico de gallo and flour tortillas.

US$18.99

Carne Asada

Tender rib'eye steak served with beans, rice, grilled onion and flour tortillas.

US$17.99

Steak A La Mexicana

Steak topped with onions, jalapeno, and tomatoes. Served with rice and beans

US$17.99

Molcajete

Grilled steak, chicken, shrimps, pork, chop, chorizo, cactus and onions with two stuffed peppers. Served with rice, beans, sour cream, salad and tortillas.

US$23.99

Arroz Con Carne

Grilled steak over bed of rice topped with cheese dip

US$15.99

Quesa-Birria Tacos

Three crispy shredded beef tacos with cheese served with beef broth on the side for dipping.

US$15.99

Asada Taco

Steak.

US$3.99

Beef Tongue Taco Platter

3 Beef Tongue Tacos

US$16.50

Grilled Chicken Taco

Chicken.

US$3.99

Camaron Taco

Shrimp.

US$3.99

Pescado Taco

Fish.

US$3.99

Al Pastor Taco

Marinated pork.

US$3.99

Taco Platter Mix

Three tacos served with rice and beans. Can mix.

US$14.99

Carnitas Taco

Pork tips.

US$3.99

Taco From the Grill

Lunch

Huevos Rancheros

Two eggs covered in ranchero sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$9.99

Lunch Acapulco

A tortilla filled with grilled steak or chicken onions and melted cheese, rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo.

US$11.25

Huevos Con Jamon

Two scrambled eggs and ham. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$9.99

Lunch Rollitos

Two flour tortillas filled with chicken or steak. Served with rice,lettuce,sour cream and pico de gallo

US$10.50

Lunch Carnitas

Fried pork tips served with rice, lettuce, sour cream, tomatoes and tortillas.

US$11.25

Huevos Con Chorizo

Two scrambled eggs cooked with Mexican sausage. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$9.99

Lunch Arroz Con Carne

Grilled steak over bed of rice topped with cheese dip

US$11.25

Lunch Quesadilla Rellena

Shredded beef or chicken quesadilla with your choice of rice or beans and a side or cream salad.

US$10.25

Lunch Fajitas

Steak or Chicken

US$11.50

Lunch Fajita Nachos

Nachos with steak or chicken grilled fajita-style topped with cheese sauce

US$11.25

Lunch Taquitos Mexicanos

One Chicken and One shredded beef, fried taquitos, served with rice and crema salad.

US$10.50

Lunch Burrito Deluxe

One beef and bean burrito or chicken and bean burrito topped with crema salad

US$9.99

Lunch Pollo Fundido

Shredded chicken cooked with jalapeno and banana peppers in a creamy white sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$10.25

Lunch Fajita Taco Salad

Bowl filled with your choice of steak or chicken grilled fajita-style, beans, cheese, sour cream, lettuce, pico.

US$11.99

Lunch Burrito California

Burrito stuffed with grilled chicken or steak, chorizo, rice and beans. Topped with cheese sauce and pico de Gallo.

US$11.25

Lunch Arroz Con Pollo

Grilled chicken strips topped with cheese sauce over bed of rice.

US$11.25

Lunch Burrito Fajita

Burrito filled with steak or chicken cooke with onions and bell peppers topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans

US$10.50

Lunch Seafood Fajita

Shrimp and scallops cooked with peppers, onions, and mushrooms

US$12.99

Lunch Chimichanga

Ground beef or chicken stuffed in a tortilla fried, cheese sauce, rice and beans.

US$9.99

Burrito Rocketa

Flour tortilla stuffed with carnitas, topped with cheese sauce, red sauce and pico de Gallo.Served with rice and beans

US$10.50

Lunch Spinach Chicken Enchiladas

2 corn tortillas stuffed with spinach and chicken, topped with our delicious poblano salsa . Served with rice and beans

US$10.50

Protein & Side Salad

Grilled chicken breast, or steak strips with a side of lettuce,guacamole and pico de gallo

US$10.99

TacoEnchi

Two Taco-Enchis which is a taco filled with an enchilada. One chicken and the other with ground beef; served with rice ,lettuce,tomatoes and sour cream

US$11.25

Lunch Wet Burrito

Burrito filled with beef, chicken, rice and beans; topped with cheese and red sauce, beef tips and sour cream.

US$11.25

Pollo Gratinado

Grilled chicken chopped with onions and covered with melted Mexican cheese.

US$11.99

Fresh Guacamole

US$11.25

Camarones Gratinados

Grilled jumbo shrimp chopped with onions and covered with melted Mexican cheese.

US$13.25

Mia's Special

Grilled steak and cheese dip over bed of French fries

US$13.00

16 Oz. Cheese Dip

US$14.99

Bean Dip

US$8.25

Jalapeno Bacon Poppers

Five jalapenos stuffed with cream cheese and wrapped in bacon

US$10.99

Chicken Tortilla Soup

A large bowl of our chicken broth with shredded chicken, rice and pico de gallo.

US$10.99

Fiesta Trio

Small cheese dip guacamole and pico de gallo.

US$12.99

8 Oz. Cheese Dip

US$8.25

La Herradura Dip

Ground Beef, Cheese Dip, Red Onions, And A Special Chile Sauce.

US$9.75

6 0z. Cheese Dip

Favorite.

US$6.25

Shrimp Tostada

Pan seared shrimp, served over three corn tostadas, topped with slices of avocado, onions, tomatoes and queso fresco. Drizzled with sour cream and our homemade chipotle sauce.

US$14.25

Queso Fundido

Melted cheese casserole with Mexican sausage and rajas.

US$10.75

Guacamole Dip

US$6.50

Appetizers

Burritos

Burrito San Polo

A hand-held burrito filled with carnitas, onions, shredded cheese, rice and beans. Garnished with lettuce and pico de Gallo

US$14.99

Burrito Dos Amigos

Obe beef burrito and one chicken chimichanga, topped with sour cream and salsa. Served with rice beans.

US$13.99

Wet Burrito

A large burrito filled with beef, chicken, rice and beans, topped with cheese, salsa, beef and sour cream.

US$14.99

Steak Burrito

A burrito stuffed with steak and onions; topped with cheese sauce and red sauce. Served with rice, beans, lettuce, sour cream and pico de Gallo

US$14.99

Burritos Deluxe (2)

Two flour tortillas combined, one chicken and beans and one beef and beans, topped with salsa, pico de gallo and sour cream.

US$11.99

Philly Steak Burrito

Thinly sliced steak meat, onion, mushrooms and roasted poblano peppers. Drizzled with a cheese rice or beans, salsa and cream.

US$14.99

Burrito Mexicano

One flour tortilla stuffed with grilled steak or chicken, rice, beans and onions. Topped with queso dip, pico de gallo and garnished with guacamole and sour cream. Served with rice and beans on the side.

US$15.99

Burritos Fajita (2)

Tortillas filled with grilled onions, choice of steak or chicken, covered with cheese sauce. Topped with sour cream. Served with rice or beans.

US$14.99

Burrito Tampico

A large burrito stuffed with shredded beef, cheese and rice, topped with chipotle cheese sauce. Served with lettuce, sour cream and pico de gallo.

US$13.99

Burrito Chipotle

One flour tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, green peppers, your choice of rice or beans, covered with a creamy chipotle sauce. Drizzled with sour cream and garnished with a mango pico de gallo.

US$15.99

Burrito Trio Grande

A large burrito filled with chicken, steak and shrimps grilled fajitas-style, stuffed with rice and beans, topped with cheese dip and red sauce.

US$16.99

Burrito De Camaron

A large burrito filled with grilled shrimps, bell pepper and onions. Served with rice and beans.

US$16.99

Chimichangas Dinner

Favorite. Two flour tortillas fried, filled with shredded beef or chicken, covered with cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans.

US$12.99

Burrito Gigante

A burrito filled with grilled steak or pork tips, rice and beans. Topped with cheese sauce, served with lettuce, sour cream and pico de Gallo

US$14.99

Burrito California

A large tortilla stuffed with grilled chicken, Mexican sausage, rice and beans, topped with cheese sauce and pico de gallo.

US$14.99

Rice And Beans

US$5.25

Pico De Gallo

US$4.75

Sour Cream

US$1.99

Guacamole Salad

Lettuce, pico de Gallo and guacamole

US$6.25

French Fries

With cheese.

US$3.99

Beans

US$3.50

Sour Cream Salad

Lettuce, pico de Gallo and sour cream

US$5.25

Extra Salsa 4 Oz.

US$1.50

8 Oz. Salsa

US$4.50

Extra Chips

US$1.50

Black Beans

US$4.00

Extra Tortillas

US$1.99

Rice

US$3.50

16 Oz. Salsa

US$7.99

Sides

Kids

8. Kids Mini Taco Salad

US$7.99

7. Kids Combo

Rice and beans (choice of one) taco, enchilada, cheese quesadilla, or burrito.

US$7.99

9. Kids Arroz Con Carne

Grilled steak over bed of rice topped with cheese dip

US$7.99

5. Kid's Corn Dog With Fries

US$7.99

4. Kid's Cheese Pizza & Fries

US$7.99

4. Kid's Pepperoni Pizza & Fries

US$7.99

2. Kid's Cheeseburger & Fries

US$7.99

6. Kid's Rice With Chicken

US$7.99

10. Kids Nachos

Beef or chicken.

US$7.99

3. Kid's Chicken Nuggets & Fries

US$7.99

1. Kid's Mac & Cheese

US$7.99

Create Your Own Combo (4)

Choose 4 Items

US$12.99

Create Your Own Combo (3)

Choose 3 Items

US$11.99

Combos

Seafood de la Casa

Camarones Al Mojo De Ajo

sauteed shrimp in garlic mojo sauce, onions, tomato and fresh avocado over rice.

US$18.99

Seafood Chimichangas

Two flour tortillas fried filled with shrimp scallops and crab meat covered with cheese sauce.

US$17.99

Arroz Con Mariscos

Shrimp and scallops topped with cheese sauce, served with rice and beans

US$18.99

Platillo Del Mar

Tilapia fish, scallops and shrimp topped with seafood sauce. Served with rice.

US$18.99

Arroz Con Camarones

Grilled shrimp over a bed of rice and cheese sauce.

US$18.99

Camarones Pablito

Shrimp on a bed of rice and california veggies, topped with cheese sauce

US$17.99

3 California Fish Tacos

Your choice of flour or corn tortillas stuffed with fish fillet, topped with fresh cabbage and Chef's salsa. Served with rice and pico de gallo.

US$14.99

Pescado Herradura

Shredded tender tilapia fillet with fresh grilled shrimp, mushrooms, spinach and roasted peppers in a delicious white wine sauce. Served with your choice or rice or mashed potatoes.

US$18.99

Coctel De Camaron

Tender shrimp with cocktail sauce ,tomatoes, onions, jalapenos, avocado, and cilantro

US$16.99

Camarones A La Diabla

Hot and spicy shrimp, served with rice and beans.

US$18.99

Chori Pollo

Grilled chicken breast covered with chorizo (Mexican sausage) and cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$16.99

Pollo Azteca

Grilled chicken breast, sauteed with shrimp, onions, corn, pineapple, and sliced poblano peppers. served with rice and tortillas

US$17.99

Pollo Supremo

Grilled chicken strips cooked with onions, bell peppers and tomatoes covered with cheese sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$15.99

Pollo Chipotle Don Jose

Grilled chicken strips cooked with onions, topped with chipotle sauce. Served with rice and beans

US$15.99

Pollo Poblano

Grilled chicken breast cooked with poblano peppers and onions, topped with cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans

US$17.99

Pollo Fundido

Shredded chicken cooked with jalapeno and banana peppers in a creamy sauce. Served with rice, beans and tortillas.

US$13.99

Pollo Relleno

Pan roasted chicken breast stuffed with sauteed vegetables and cheese, creamy chipotle sauce and black beans.

US$11.99

Pollo Bambino

Two gried flour tortillas filled with chicken topped with cheese sauce, red salsa, sour cream. Served with rice and beans.

US$12.99

Pollo Loco

Grilled chicken breast and california veggies covered with cheese sauce. Served with rice and beans

US$16.99

Arroz Con Pollo

Favorite. Grilled chicken over a bed of rice and cheese sauce.

US$14.99

Chicken

Drinks

Unsweet Tea

US$3.99

Barq's Root Beer

A sweet, spiced favorite that’s stood the test of time.

US$3.99

Diet Coke

A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.

US$3.99

Minute Maid Lemonade

100% Pure squeezed pasteurized orange juice. A delicious orange juice with a taste that’s the next best thing to fresh squeezed.

US$3.99

Coke

The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.

US$3.99

Pibb Xtra

An intensely flavored, refreshing, spicy cherry alternative to regular cola.

US$3.99

Sweet Tea

US$3.99

Cherry Coke

Enjoy the crisp and refreshing taste with sweet, smooth cherry flavor.

US$3.99

Coke Zero

The same great taste but with zero calories.

US$3.99